Register to ask Dr. Bo a question, or comment on any question/answer.
Register!

one moment please...


Bo takes a critical thinking-, reason-, and science-based approach to issues that matter with the goal of educating and entertaining. You create the show by submitting your questions here. Bo has a PhD in social psychology, but covers a broad range of topics including: Science Education (scientific method, what is / is not science, etc.), Success, Entrepreneurship, Motivation, General Psychology, Social Psychology, Positive Psychology (well-being, flourishing, happiness, etc.), Cognitive Psychology (belief, cognitive biases, memory, our flawed brain, etc.), General Social Science, Critical Thinking, Logical Fallacies, Humanism / Secularism, and even some Philosophy. All (reasonable) questions will be answered here, and some will be the material for the Dr. Bo Show.

The first two years of shows have been compiled into the book, Reason: Book I. This book is available in hardcover, ebook, and audiobook through Amazon and all major ebook retailers.

Q&A Home Contact Form



Send me a copy of this message
Send Message sending message...

Q&A Home Question

0

votes

image loading...
Dudley Dowell
belief
karma
Tue, Apr 28, 2015 - 12:00 AM

Is there any truth to the idea of "Karma"?


1 Answer

0

votes
Answer Accepted!

image loading...
Bo Bennett, PhD
Host, Doctor of Social Psychology

Moderator

image loading...

Bo Bennett, PhD

Host, Doctor of Social Psychology

Moderator

About Bo Bennett, PhD

I am the host of this show :) For my complete bio, please see http://www.bobennett.com.
PrintTue, Apr 28, 2015 - 12:00 AM


Strangely, one of my strongest childhood memories is when I called my brother an idiot, and two minutes later I stubbed my toe.  My brother told me that God was punishing me—that seemed to make sense to me given the Catholic framework in which I was raised.  Perhaps if I were raised as a Buddhist, my brother would have told me it was "Karma," or a spiritual theory of moral causation that states people get what they deserve.  This is a fairly common belief adopted by many cultures that has real effects on our behavior and on society.

First, an important rule of critical thought: a universal law cannot be logically assumed from an anecdote or personal experience.  We all have had times when we felt the effects of what could be Karma—we do something bad to someone, then something bad happens to us.  Through subjective validation, even a slight belief in Karma will result in hyper-sensitivity when it comes to making sense of coincidences, in order to support the belief in Karma.

A similar concept to "Karma" is the "Just world hypothesis," which helps people deal with injustice.  For example, if I see a homeless person, instead of having painful and negative feelings, my belief in a just world (or Karma) alleviates my own discomfort as I tell myself that the homeless person is getting what he deserves.  This concept has been explored by researchers Melvin J. Lerner and Carolyn H. Simmons back in 1966 (for more details, see http://www.sociallypsyched.org/item/the-innocent-victim).

The belief in Karma is often, but not always, associated with reincarnation.  To believers, it is very clear in some cases, such as with the starving children in Africa, that they did nothing to deserve their fate.  Rather than abandon Karma, it could just be extended to past lives—so that little starving African child, he was probably Hitler.  Now you can sleep better at night and spend that money on a cup of coffee rather than donating it to a campaign with the goal of feeding children who are really only getting what they deserve.



Another cognitive bias that cultivates belief in Karma is our tendency to notice the hits but ignore the misses (a form of the confirmation bias).  A good example of this is found with Bernie Madoff, the guy who in 2009 was convicted of swindling an estimated $64.8 billion from investors.  In his case, it appears that Karma is very real, however, for every Madoff there are thousands of others who get off with no more than a slap on the wrist (admittedly, most for lesser crimes).  The media fosters the idea of Karma by reporting stories of justice—this is what we, the public, desire.



A form of Karma certainly does exist; it exists as a social phenomenon fueled by our own beliefs, guilt, and cognitive biases.  For example, if we steal, we have social rules (laws, in this case) that are in place to promote justice.  If we don't get caught, we might experience guilt and through subjective validation, connect any negative event to the act of stealing, when in reality, the two are events are independent.  It is also known that guilt can lead to self-sabotage, and the belief that one deserves good fortune acts as motivation to make good fortune more probable for that person.  The important difference between the kind of "Karma" explained psychologically and socially, and some magical brand of divine or universal law, is that in the latter, the results of "Karma" are not objectively measurable but exist in the minds of the believers.  In the case of self-sabotage and motivation, "Karma" is the result of modified behavior stemming from belief.



Should we believe in Karma?  I certainly don't think so.  First, because evidence clearly does not support such a phenomenon (that should be reason enough) and second, because it is imperative that we don't blame victims and make those who have good fortune into gods.  We live in a world that is not always fair, and not always just.  What goes around does not always come around, and many times people reap more than then they sow.  It is up to us to help and offer sympathy those who need it and not expect "Karma" to pay us back, and do good simply for goodness sake.
Bo Bennett, PhD
My Latest Book: https://www.uncomfortable-ideas.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thedrboshow/
About Me: http://www.bobennett.com

Podcast Episode: Do You Believe in Karma? Should You?

Subscribe via iTunes! and please leave a review there if you like this podcast!



Quick Comment On This Answer (no login required):
Your comment below will be anonymously sent to the answer owner, it will not be posted, and you will not get a response.

Send Comment sending comment...

Registered User Comments

Deborah
Thursday, April 30, 2015 - 01:23:38 PM
Karma is a bitch... only if you are. I believe in Karma for sure as in the form of self- sabotoge on a very subconscience level. I don't believe it's the universe taking revenge on you. If you ever watched an episode of "Worlds Dumbest Criminals" you would agree.

login to reply
0 replies
1 votes
 


working...

Linda Williams
Tuesday, April 28, 2015 - 02:10:49 PM
Dr Bo, If Karma is a belief, wouldn't the believer have to believe in some kind of power in the universe, making it come about? That being said, isn't Karma just another name for God!

login to reply
1 reply
1 votes
 


working...
 

Bo Bennett, PhD
moderator
Tuesday, April 28, 2015 - 02:19:53 PM
Good point, Linda. "God" can be defined in many ways. The basis of Karma does seem to require a god-like figure (or many gods) who dish out justice to mortals, but doesn't necessitate such a being or beings according to some. I wouldn't want to attempt to argue for Karma without something very much like a god behind it.

login to reply
 
2 votes
 


working...




 Copyright 2017, Archieboy Holdings, LLC.